• Realistic wind power
    December 29,2012
     

    Realistic wind power

    Beyond the complex technical issues and jargon, the wind debate is filled with emotion, politics, and financial issues that make it very difficult to have an informed dialog and make rational decisions. Confucius said, “Any man can make long journey, takes smart man to know which direction.” Agreeing on reasonable and realistic goals is an essential prerequisite to any energy discussion.

    In his letter on Dec. 12, Bob Walker mentioned a state goal of “90 percent renewable power by 2050.” If he was referring to achieving 90 percent of the total Vermont average baseload — about 900 megawatts (MW), then according to the Vermont Energy Partnership (VTEP) website, that goal is unachievable. VTEP reports that about 82 square miles of Vermont land is suitable for installing wind towers and that if all of that land was used (about 320 towers), it would provide only 10 percent of Vermont’s total needs.

    The financial incentives mostly come from the state’s Standard Offer Program that mandates that the utilities must buy any power generated by wind or solar at eight times the current market price. This is on top of the 1.8 cents/kW federal subsidy. A single 1.5 MW-rated tower could earn $405,000 in power sales plus $675,000 in subsidies per year. Reduced by actual load factors still generates a low of $356,000 per year, per tower.

    There is a reason why Germany, Denmark, Spain, Japan and six other countries have stopped wind subsidies, cancelled projects and even dismantled existing sites. Wind uses the most land, has the lowest capacity factor, the highest costs, and the highest ongoing maintenance per usable kilowatt of any energy source.

    We need renewable energy sources but we also need to be smart enough to move in the right direction.

    Tom Watkins

    Montpelier

    MORE IN Letters
    With ample justification, Americans love their democracy and it is only natural if they believe... Full Story
    On the sixth day, when God was creating man and woman, he decided to have some fun. Full Story
    Violence must stop Full Story
    More Articles
  •  
     
    • MEDIA GALLERY 
    • VIDEOS
    • PHOTOS